To Trade or Not to Trade: Managing Emotional Trades in a Volatile Market
Published September 12, 2024
Featured Image

Volatility plays a pivotal role in financial markets, especially during periods of significant news events that influence asset prices. News trading, characterized by trading in response to these news-driven price movements, presents unique challenges and opportunities for traders. Many traders attempt to capitalize on these high volatility environments by scalping profits; however, the rapid and pronounced price swings can significantly elevate risks. Slow decision-making, inadequate risk management, and high slippage are common pitfalls that can adversely affect trading outcomes.

Despite these challenges, many traders lack transparency regarding their performance during high or low volatility. While there is no definitive right or wrong approach to news trading, it is essential for traders to understand whether they typically outperform or underperform during such times.

Disclaimer

In this article, we examine the impact of high versus low volatility on trading performance. Understanding how volatility affects trading outcomes is crucial for both novice and experienced traders. We explore the risks and issues traders face in high versus low volatility environments and demonstrate how data-driven insights from Hoc-trade analytics can benefit your trading strategy.

The Role of Volatility in Trading

Volatility can be illustrated as a wind for windsurfer

Volatility is essential in financial markets as it provides opportunities for profit. However, it also introduces risk, particularly for less experienced traders. Think of volatility in trading as the wind for windsurfers. Just as wind is essential for windsurfers, volatility is crucial for traders navigating the financial markets. Without wind, surfing is impossible; with a gentle breeze, beginners can practice safely.

However, as the wind strengthens, it creates conditions that are ideal for experienced surfers who can manage the challenges and enjoy the excitement. Similarly, high market volatility provides opportunities for skilled traders to profit, but it also presents significant risks for novices.

Illustration to a volatile market

High Volatility: Opportunities and Risks

During periods of high volatility, market prices fluctuate rapidly. This environment requires traders to make quick decisions, as positions can quickly move into deep profit or loss. High volatility is often driven by news events or significant market activities, creating fast and strong price movements.

News events can also trigger FOMO (fear of missing out) among traders, compelling them to react impulsively to market movements. However, without a specific trading plan in place, traders often find themselves lost in the chaos, resulting in closing positions either too late or too early.

For experienced traders, high volatility can be lucrative. These traders typically have robust risk management strategies, such as stop-loss orders and strict money management rules, to protect their capital. They thrive on rapid market movements and can capitalize on the increased opportunities.

How High vs. Low Volatile market impacts traders’ psychology

In contrast, new or less experienced traders may struggle during high volatility. The need for quick decision-making can lead to reliance on intuition, which is not always reliable in trading.

In high volatility markets, the speed of price movements requires quick decision-making, which poses its own challenges such as:

  • Intuition-Based Decisions

New or less experienced may rely on intuition instead of a well-defined strategy, especially during times of high volatility as things are rapidly changing. This results in suboptimal choices such as moving stop-loss orders farther away or closing profitable positions too early.

  • Increased Risk

High volatility can trigger substantial price swings, quickly hitting stop-loss orders and potentially leading to greater losses if not properly managed.

  • Increased Slippage

News events are oftentimes accompanied by widened spreads as liquidity providers adjust for the high volatility. As a result, both trade entry and exit may have significantly unfavorable spreads, lowering your overall profitability. Moreover, high volatility may cause significant slippage, potentially lowering your payoff even further. Traders should be aware and account for those special trading environments.

Low Volatility: Stability and Learning Environment

Low volatility periods offer a more stable environment for trading. Prices move more predictably, providing a safer space for new traders to practice and develop their skills. During these times, experienced traders may stay on the sidelines, finding the lack of movement unexciting and less profitable.

Trade performance during High vs. Low volatility as detected by Hoc-trade

Let’s look at this example. During high volatility, traders made a minor profit of 0.1 pips per trade on average. Out of 438 trades, the total payoff was around $440 USD. On the contrary, during low volatility, traders achieved a significantly higher profit of 2 pips per trade on average. With 1062 trades, the total payoff exceeded $9,000 USD.

What does this indicate? It is revealed that, despite the substantial opportunities high volatility can offer, it often leads to lower average profits for this trader.

Improving Performance and Managing Risk

Understanding personal performance in different volatility levels is vital for optimizing trading strategies. Traders can use tools and analytics to review their performance and identify patterns. For instance, if you consistently perform worse during high volatility, you may choose to focus on low volatility periods or adjust your strategies to mitigate risks.

One practical approach is to lower the lot size during high volatility, allowing for wider stop-loss and take-profit levels without increasing overall risk. This adjustment can help manage the higher price fluctuations typical of volatile markets.

Additionally, using technical indicators like Bollinger Bands can help traders gauge market volatility and make more informed decisions. Bollinger Bands, which plot standard deviations away from a moving average, provide visual cues about market volatility and potential price movements.

Bollinger Bands as a risk management technique

Risk Management Strategies

To navigate volatile markets, here are various risk management techniques that you can employ to navigate high volatility:

Use of Stop-Loss Orders

To limit potential losses, stop-loss orders are essential. Tight stop-loss orders might be hit frequently in high volatility, so adjusting the lot size to set wider stop-loss levels without increasing risk is advisable.

Stop-loss illustration

Technical Indicators

Indicators like Bollinger Bands help traders visualize volatility and make informed decisions. Bollinger Bands show the range of price movements based on standard deviations from a moving average, helping traders identify periods of high and low volatility.

Utilize Hoc-trade to Automate Trading Analysis

Alternatively, you can let Hoc-trade automatically assess your current trading performance to determine if you are at risk from high market volatility. Hoc-trade will identify negative correlations between high market volatility and the performance of trades during those times. If your trades consistently show losses on average during periods of high volatility, you will be notified that news trading has been detected in your trades.

Hoc-trade performance overview if your performance doesn’t affected by high volatile market

This analysis is classified based on underlying volatility at trade entry using the Bollinger Bands indicator. In the analysis ‘Profit High vs. Low Volatility,’ the average return per trade is measured depending on the level of volatility at the time of trade opening. Each trade is classified as having been opened during high or low volatility (measured through indicators). Return (%) is calculated as the trade outcome divided by the balance at the time of trade opening.

Hoc-trade chart on trade performance during High vs. Low volatility

By leveraging tools like the Hoc-trade Analytics tool, traders can gain insights into their performance across different market conditions. Adjusting strategies based on these insights, such as managing lot sizes and using technical indicators, can help traders navigate the complexities of volatility and improve their overall trading outcomes.

Conclusion

Understanding and managing the impacts of volatility is crucial for successful trading. While high volatility presents lucrative opportunities, it also brings higher risks and requires a disciplined approach. By leveraging analytical tools, practicing sound risk management, and continuously improving their strategies, traders can navigate both high and low volatility environments more effectively.

Ready to approach your trading with more rationality? Connect your trading account with Hoc-trade for free today and experience the power of AI-driven assistance in managing your emotions and optimizing your trades.

👉🏻 Sign up now for free at hoc-trade.com